Saturday, June 25, 2016

The Sea Ranch Paradox, or How One of my Least Favorite Architects Designed One of my Most Favorite Places

sea ranch 50
Sea Ranch Condominium 1 by MLTW (1966). Photo ©Darren Bradley

The Sea Ranch is an architectural masterpiece. Mention that you are visiting this mythical place to just about any architect or designer, and you are almost certain to get a look of wistful longing in return - tinged perhaps with a bit of jealousy. And what's not to love? It's really a masterful blending of architecture and nature in a stunningly beautiful environment. Even people who claim not to like modernist architecture are taken in by its beauty. And yet, one of its principal creators, Charles Moore, was an architect who later became a champion of the Post-Modern Movement, embracing kitschy and almost cartoonish themes in his work. 



bradley_sea ranch_7
Entrance to Sea Ranch Lodge & Store by Joseph Esherick (1964). Statue by Robert Holmes. Photo ©Darren Bradley

From the beginning, everyone knew that the Sea Ranch was going to be a special place. This stretch of rugged, desolate coastline about 100 miles north of San Francisco was in an area that was relatively free of development. Oceanic Properties, the real estate subsidiary of one of Hawaii's "Big Five" corporations, Castle & Cooke, bought the land in 1964 with the intention of developing an ecologically sensitive community that would harmonize with the beauty of the natural surroundings. It was going to be free of the normal commercial pressures that generally going along with real estate speculation and development. 


573_6A
Lawrence & Anna Halprin, and Charles Moore at Sea Ranch (1966). Photo by Lawrence Halprin Collection, The Architectural Archives, University of Pennsylvania.

The guy on point for Oceanic Properties, Al Boeke, had a very specific vision. He hired landscape architect Lawrence Halprin, to do a complete study of the area to do a development plan that would be sensitive to the local ecology, microclimates, wind, and other conditions. 


Continuous_Catherine 4
One of Lawrence Halprin's original site plans for Sea Ranch development. 

The site consisted of 5,000 acres of windswept, rocky coastline with a series of exposed, relatively flat meadows on bluffs overlooking the ocean, and then turning into protected, wooded hills after a few hundred yards. The Highway 1 essentially acts as the dividing line between the two typologies. The occasional row of cyprus trees had previously been planted in the meadows to act as wind breaks, and run perpendicular to the shoreline.


sea ranch aerial
Vintage aerial view of Sea Ranch


sea ranch 35
One of the many "hedgerows" of cyprus trees that serve as windbreaks along the shoreline. Photo ©Darren Bradley


Boeke then hired Joseph Esherick for the design of the store/sales office in 1965, and for the first houses shortly thereafter. 
sea ranch 29a
Store and restaurant (now also lobby for lodge). Photo ©Darren Bradley
sea ranch 30
Store and restaurant (and now lodge). Photo ©Darren Bradley
sea ranch 18
The famed Sea Ranch Ram's Head logo designed by Barbara Stauffacher. Al Boeke loved it so much, he had it put on everything.
Photo ©Darren Bradley
sea ranch 31
Interior of the lobby / restaurant. Photo ©Darren Bradley

sea ranch 9
Sea Ranch Lodge. Photo ©Darren Bradley

sea ranch 10
Sea Ranch Lodge. Photo ©Darren Bradley

sea ranch 12
Detail of the exit signs at the lodge. Photo ©Darren Bradley

sea ranch 44
One of the few original Esherick-designed houses that still has a sod roof. Photo ©Darren Bradley

The architectural firm of Moore, Lyndon, Turnbull, Whitaker (MLTW) were brought in to design an series of condominiums in 1965. The plan was to have Esherick design small clusters of homes in and around the trees of the windbreaks. MLTW would design condos that would sit on the bluffs in the meadows. It would be Moore's first major project. 

sea ranch 49


Admittedly, I first knew of Charles Moore's work through his later post-modernist projects from the 1970s and 80s. And frankly, they're not really my thing. Once, when visiting New Orleans many years ago, I came across a chintzy caricature of an Italianate piazza in bright, gaudy colors. I had no idea who designed it but assumed it was some sort of cheap, temporary exhibit. I only found out later that it was a seminal example of post-modernist architecture by none other than Charles Moore...


piazza d'italia moore
Charles Moore's Piazza d'Italia in New Orleans was hailed as an architectural masterpiece upon its completion in 1978. I don't get it. When I first saw it, I thought it was a joke. Anyway, it fell into ruin shortly thereafter until it was fully restored in 2003. 

And let's not forget that this is also the same Charles Moore who replaced William Pereira as campus architect at the University of California Irvine. Moore treated his predecessor's work with complete disregard and lack of respect. 

Besides irrevocably modifying the unique, park-like circular campus plan that Pereira had planned, he changed the design language from modernist to... well, this: 
University-ExtensionAlumni-Center
UC Irvine Extension Alumni Center. Photo courtesy of UCI. 

But that was to come many years later. These were still early days, and modernism was still the thing - even for Charles Moore. For the Sea Ranch Condominium project, Moore turned to local vernacular architecture, such as the former barns of the sheep ranch that previously occupied the site.


sea ranch 14
One of the old barns from when Sea Ranch was a sheep ranch. Today, it sits empty save for some swallows nesting.
Photo ©Darren Bradley

He was also greatly inspired by the chapel at nearby Fort Ross - the former Russian colony that once occupied this territory in the early 19th century. 
sea ranch 45
Russian Orthodox Chapel at Fort Ross. Photo ©Darren Bradley

Overall, though, Moore felt that the building would have to have a certain mass to avoid being completely dwarfed by the vast, open territory around it. For that reason, he felt that condos were more suited than houses to this land. 


sea ranch 1
Moore referred to Condominium 1 as "the Wooden Rock". Photo ©Darren Bradley

Moore claims that his firm and Esherick did not coordinate or communicate at all about their respective designs, but still ended up using basically the same design solutions because that's what the environment called for. This included sloping shed roofs angled to deflect the wind, no eaves or overhangs that could be ripped off by the strong gusts, and interior courtyards and protected gardens. Essentially, allow people to enjoy the sun without being blown away by the wind. Also, because of the strong spray of salt water coming off the ocean, which tends to coat windows, Moore didn't want a lot of clerestories - at least not too high up so they'd be hard to access and wash. 


sea ranch 34
The first phase of single-family homes at Sea Ranch by Joseph Esherick was built in small clusters, in and around the cyprus tree windbreaks. This allowed for the meadows to be largely free of development. Photo ©Darren Bradley

Condominium 1, completed in 1966, was the stunning result. From the outside, it evokes a modernist version of a medieval village or farming community. 
sea ranch 28
Entrance to Condo 1. Photo ©Darren Bradley

The terraced compound mirrors the sloping hillside terrain adjacent to the ocean cliffs. There is an outer courtyard for the cars. 


sea ranch 27
Carpark courtyard at Condo 1. Photo ©Darren Bradley

Passing through a tunnel, you will find a much more intimate and protected courtyard intended to spend time relaxing out of the wind. One feels at once both exposed to nature and protected from it. Anyone who's ever spent time on an old farm in Europe will recognize the design language. 


sea ranch 47
Tunnel leading from the outer courtyard to the inner courtyard. Photo ©Darren Bradley

sea ranch 48
Looking up the steeply sloped hill within the inner courtyard. Photo ©Darren Bradley
sea ranch 4
Looking down the slop of the inner courtyard to the ocean below. Photo ©Darren Bradley

sea ranch 3
Access to the ocean bluffs from the courtyard is through another tunnel. Photo ©Darren Bradley

sea ranch 2
Interior courtyard. Photo ©Darren Bradley

sea ranch 26
Photo ©Darren Bradley
The barn theme is further reinforced inside. Each unit is essentially a wide-open, double or triple-height space. both the walls and posts and beams are made of untreated, rough-hewn timber. 
sea ranch 40
Interior of Unit 7 of Condominium 1. Note the kitchen "pod" and the edge "four-poster" on the right are visible.
Photo ©Darren Bradley

sea ranch 8
The concept is that the occupants are protected by the barn-like structure, and then further layers of protection and functionality are provided by the free-standing pods for eating, sleeping, washing, etc. Photo ©Darren Bradley

sea ranch 7
View of the conversation pit area, which is meant to be a small, intimate space within the larger, open barn. This area is directly below from where the previous photo was taken. Photo ©Darren Bradley
Within each unit there are essentially two miniature "houses" that feel like a space within a space. One is a kitchen/bathroom area, and the other is a sort of sleeping pod suspended on four posts above the living area, and accessible via a catwalk from a staircase. 

sea ranch 42


True to Moore's ideas, the windows are low to the ground but the space is light-filled and open, while cozy and intimate at the same time. You are constantly aware of the beautiful but harsh natural landscape surrounding you, while also feeling protected from it. 
sea ranch 41
Plan of the ten-unit condominium 1. Note the courtyard spaces and the very similar plans for each unit. 
There were originally supposed to be nine or ten of these condo clusters built along the cliffs near the main store, and south of there. But Condominium 1 was the only complex that was built. Moore attributes the lack of additional phases to the greed of the real estate agents working for the development. He says they found they could get their commissions much faster by selling the land as individual parcels to build private homes, rather than waiting for condos to be built, so they lobbied Oceanic to not move forward. 


sea ranch 5
Photo ©Darren Bradley

The result is that there is only one other condo complex at Sea Ranch, and it's a small building just behind Condominium 1. But this was not designed by MLTW, or even approved by the design committee. In fact, Moore hated the design and called the architect "a designer of ski condos", which I believe he meant as an insult. 


sea ranch 38
Photo ©Darren Bradley

While the Sea Ranch did change somewhat from the original vision as laid out by Boeke, Halprin, Esherick, and MLTW, it remains today remarkably cohesive in its design principles and appearance. The community, which stretches for several miles on both sides of Highway 1, generally observes the same design guidelines established by the founding group. 


sea ranch 43
Sliding barn doors, vertical wood siding, and shed roofs a plenty at Sea Ranch! Photo ©Darren Bradley
sea ranch 21
I really like this one but I don't think Mr. Moore would have approved. For one, it has glass windows too high up to reach. Also, its shed roof is sloping the wrong direction to be of any use against the wind. Photo ©Darren Bradley

This style, which has come to be known as "Sea Ranch Vernacular", inspired countless suburban shopping centers and apartment buildings around the country. It quickly became cliché and was the de facto style throughout the 70s and into the 80s. Unfortunately, most of those are rather poor imitations of the real thing. There are also some pretty poor imitations right in Sea Ranch, as a matter of fact. 
sea ranch 33
This don't even make an attempt to integrate into the environment or the tree line. Some even have suburban-like lawns and landscaped yards!  Photo ©Darren Bradley
By the way, Moore wasn't the only architect rediscovering barns as inspiration in 1965. In fact, A. Quincy Jones was looking for a new place to live that same year after losing the house he'd designed to a wildfire. He settled on a large wooden barn-like structure in Century City that had been a photography studio. Jones converted the space into both a studio and residence which he called... "The Barn". Inside, the concept of interior spaces within spaces is very similar to the MLTW Condominium One concept. 


jones barn
Who wore it better? This is A. Quincy Jones' Barn. Photo from listing. 

I admit that before coming to Sea Ranch, I wanted to hate this place largely because I'd experienced so many of those bad imitations of the style before-hand. But I have to admit that the original examples are quite beautiful and also ingenious. The just work here , and I find the whole place to be magical. 
sea ranch 23
The awesomely named Moonraker Rec Center. I didn't see Jaws, alas. Or James. Note the deep berms to keep the wind out. Designed by MLTW. Photo ©Darren Bradley
sea ranch 24
Moonraker Pool. Photo ©Darren Bradley
sea ranch 25
Interior changing room at Moonraker Pool, with showers up on the landing of the stairs and a sauna at the top. Note the use of the supergraphics, which Moore employed frequently. Most were designed and painted by Barbara Stauffacher, who also designed the Ram's Head logo used for all things Sea Ranch. 
sea ranch 22
Ohlson Rec Center. Photo ©Darren Bradley
sea ranch 37
Even the horses get the Sea Ranch treatment. Photo ©Darren Bradley
sea ranch 19
Sea Ranch Chapel by James Hubbell (1985). Photo ©Darren Bradley
sea ranch 20
Interior of the Sea Ranch Chapel by James Hubbell (1985). Photo ©Darren Bradley

Charles Moore had a different view, however, and wrote just seven years after its construction that he considered the whole place to be a failure. This seems strange to me when you consider today how close the community adheres to the design guidelines originally established. But in the book, A Place of Houses, Moore offers a rather scathing critique of what has become arguably his most celebrated creation. 

It's admittedly a bit difficult to discern just what, exactly, Moore doesn't like about his seminal project. Now, as an architectural photographer, I have to say that I know a fair number of architects. In fact, most of my closest friends are architects, so I get to hear frequently the disappointments of a finished project vs. what was initially designed. Architecture is all about compromises and there is a fair amount of heartbreak in just about every project, as one is forced to sacrifice some of their vision. Builders, developers, local governments, and especially clients are notorious for diluting the architect's original design concepts. It's frankly a miracle anything ever gets built. 
sea ranch 15
The Sea Ranch Lodge was another target of Moore's criticism. He felt it lacked the refinement of his own work, and also crowded Esherick's building next to it. Also, he didn't like the parking lots. 
But Moore's criticisms about The Sea Ranch seem to go beyond the standard disappointment of a diluted architectural vision. In fact, if anything, Moore appears upset for having created the Sea Ranch vernacular design style, and for having it followed so closely. He even states that there shouldn't have been any guidelines at all (while at the same time criticizing with specific examples many of the homes that have strayed the furthest from it. 

Anyway, the architect claims that the classic shed roof style has been poorly interpreted by numerous other architects and clients at Sea Ranch, who faced the rooflines in the wrong direction for the prevailing winds, and other sins. He claims this came from having both clients and architects who were not familiar with the terrain and didn't understand how to design for it. 
sea ranch 46
Moore particularly hated this house, which he felt did little to adapt or blend into its environment or adhere to the guidelines. This is ironic considering Moore's later legacy of completely disregarding all of those points, himself. Photo ©Darren Bradley
Moore's criticisms not withstanding, I have to say that now more than 50 years on, The Sea Ranch has aged beautifully. And the dedication of the residents to adhere to the original vision as closely as possible is to be admired. I can't think of very many other places in the world where this is so. 


sea ranch 32
Unit 9 of Condominium 1, seen here, was Charles Moore's own unit. Photo ©Darren Bradley
In 1991, Condominium 1 received the AIA Twenty-five year award, and Moore was awarded the AIA Gold Medal. The building was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2005. Moore died in 1993 at aged 68. 


The-Sea-Ranch-at-50-5
From left: Richard Whitaker, Donlyn Lyndon, Charles Moore, and William Turnbull at the Sea Ranch. 

8 comments:

colinbisset.com said...

My initial thought was how no one could do wrong in such a stunning site. I find the use of wood too much but then your photo of Condo 1 made me see why it's so good - that village shaping. The graphics are great, too, and it's wonderful they haven't been 'updated' or eliminated. It does make me think of a million ski resorts, though...

Boris said...

Beautifully written essay! I think it was Goldberger who wrote something like "Architecture is a response to limits".

Deep shadows are very impressive.

Who tripped the shutter in the courtyard shot?

;-)

Martin Schmidt said...

Did a VRBO house and had the family at Sea Ranch at the north end by the golf course for week back in March of this year. The clustering of the houses + site planning allowing views from every property, the wildlife, the trails and the retention of nature separates this project from any other that I have ever experienced. Great story and thoughts, but you overlooked the role that Lawrence Halpirn played in the site planning and blending of nature and the development.

Darren Bradley said...

Thank you, Colin. I know exactly what you mean!

Darren Bradley said...

Thanks, Boris! Appreciate you stopping by for a read! It's a great spot - very photogenic. And my timer on my shutter came in handy, as usual!

Darren Bradley said...

Thank you for your comments, Martin. I agree with you that the landscape architecture was a critical element of the project's success. I actually mention Halprin quite a bit, in the beginning of the post, and there is a photo of him and the landscape plan. I agree that the title of the post is a bit misleading, perhaps, but I thought I gave him plenty of credit in what I wrote in the article.

Sharmin Info said...

Hi there

I want to share with you about architect and design conceptPlanning and Design of Correctional Facilities: Over the last several years, the planning and design profession has gained significant knowledge of what constitutes a normalized and therapeutic environment. To know more deatils visit- http://havardcooper.com
-: Havard Cooper

Thanks and Welcome
HC

Mridul Kabra said...

Hi, have a look at my website as well:

what is design
japan pavilion
architecture definition
roman colosseum facts
types of contractor
reasons to be an architect
roman pantheon architecture
what is vastu shastra